06.15.08
Having a baby in Italy
We had already dipped our toes into the waters of the socialized medical system here in Italy. A couple of routine checkups, funny rashes on the kids, that kind of thing. Having baby #4 was a headlong dive in. Health insurance is the US is sky high, if you can even afford it. Those who hear that we pay about $600 per year to buy into the Italian system think that Italy must have found the solution. But I think you get what you pay for.
Overall, we had a great experience. The nurses were more than friendly, and seemed to be more available than I remember the nurses were with our other kids. The doctors were often in a rush when they made their daily rounds, which seemed about how I remember it in the US. But when there’s no bill coming at the end of your stay, there’s less of a rush to cram all of the treatments and all of the tests into a short time frame.
But that’s about where the similarities end. We were given a list of supplies we needed to bring with us to the hospital. I was surprised at what wasn’t included. You bring your own nightgown and robe. You were on your own to bring many of the supplies needed for personal care after the baby was born. You also bring clothes for the baby. Silverware wasn’t included - we found out you’re supposed to bring your own. And the meals were pretty scant. Breakfast was two slices of dry pre-packaged toast, and a hot drink made with barley and milk. And every room but one had at least one other person in it. The larger rooms had three women!
So on one hand, you have the US system. It’s expensive, but looks like a nice hotel compared to what we had just experienced. And you have the Italian system, which is good care but absolutely no frills.
If the US were to ever switch to something like that, I have a feeling that a lot of the frills would have to be cut. People would be more responsible to provide some of their own care. And I’m not sure that everyone is willing to make that sacrifice.
The issue of health care is a big one in the US right now. The system as it is can’t continue, but how do you fix it? When will the most powerful nation in the world start doing what it takes to take care of its citizens? Will people be willing to sacrifice the little amenities (like silverware!) to make things less costly for everyone?
Amy said,
06.15.08 at 1:51 pm
Interesting to hear your firsthand account and comparison of the heathcare systems, Brian. Thanks. Dan and I have recently watched the documentary, “Sicko” by Micheal Moore. While you may or may not agree with him as a person, this is a fabulous film worth watching as the US continues to look forward and struggle with this issue of health care. He visits several other countries in Europe and also Cuba to compare. You might find it interesting. I’d highly recommend it.